Snapped Shot

Always Watching the All-Seeing Eye

 

Your "Green" Is Killing Me

You know, when the hype started growing about compact fluorescent light bulbs (CFL), people were all excited about the reduction in the production of carbon dioxide produced from the decreased energy needs. But, there are a few things that they refused to tell you.

It's like someone telling you that putting a snake in your home will do wonders by keeping the rodents away. It will save you hundreds of dollars by not having to purchase rat traps or using nasty poisons around your home. What they don't tell you is that you are buying and placing a dangerous and deadly snake in your home.

These CFL's are no different.

We are already aware of the dangers from broken mercury-filled bulbs. Some toxic waste facilities state that they want $2,000 dollars to just clean up a broken bulb. Why?? It's MERCURY!!!!

Mercury is a hazardous, toxic, deadly heavy-metal that government's the world over are working to eradicate from our lives.

And yet, these same governments are pushing, and have mandated, laws that force us to buy mercury-containing products and place them in our homes and around our children.
And like the snake you bought to save money, this decision has darker problems. Namely, the fact that all of these CFL's that have been created are made by removing mercury from the ground and processing it in order to construct the CFL's. Don't think that this is a benign enterprise:

Energy efficiency for the First World comes at a high cost for factory workers in China, with high rates of mercury poisoning being reported among employees in the plants that make compact fluorescent light bulbs.


It gets worse. The snake is angry:

According to a recent study by the Chinese health ministry, however, mercury exposure is widespread among the workers making these bulbs. At one factory in Jinzhou, 121 of 123 employees contained a dangerous body burden of mercury, with one worker carrying 150 times the government-mandated threshold. At a factory in Anyang, 35 percent of workers had suffered from mercury poisoning and the plant was dumping mercury directly into the local water supply.

Interviews conducted by the London Times turned up hundreds of cases of dangerous mercury exposure and even hospitalization, but many workers are afraid to complain for fear of losing their jobs.

The paper also turned up a case where 68 of 72 workers at one factory had required hospitalization for mercury poisoning.


If 9 million CFL's have been sold in the California alone, that means about 100 lbs of mercury has been removed from the ground and placed into the environment ready to do untold toxic damage.

And this from THE Greenest state in the Union???

If even one bulb breaks out in the open, such as in a landfill, that ONE BULB can contaminate up to 6,000 gallons of water. Not to mention the soils as well.

Oh, but the EPA has the answer. And, it only takes 19 steps to safely clean up a mercury spill from a broken CFL. Meanwhile, while you are going to be forced to buy those mercury bulbs after 2011 (if sanity does not return to this nation), the EPA has instructions for what you are to do should you have mercury in your house.

Ironic, huh?


* All mercury-containing products or containers of mercury should be placed inside a larger container with a tight fitting lid.

* Kitty litter or oil-absorbent matter should be placed around the product to protect it from breaking or sudden shocks.

* Clearly label storage container as "Mercury - DO NOT OPEN."

* If you must wait for a hazardous waste collection day, store products safely in their original containers with the labels intact, and keep them out of reach of children and pets.

* Transport container to a household hazardous collection center in a cardboard box. Secure them so that they do not tip over. This will minimize shifting or sliding during sudden stops or turns.

* Transport containers in the back of a pick-up truck or in a car trunk. If you must transport in the passenger compartment, make sure there is adequate ventilation.


Who said that the government can't have a sense of humor?

But, what if you do break a bulb? Who do you call? The EPA? No, they have no clue other than giving you steps to follow. According to those steps, you are to take those bulbs to a certified recycling center. Many times, having to pay $$ to have a single hazardous-to-your-health, toxic heavy-metal-carrying, non-freely chosen CFL bulb disposed of. Many states have only one certified recycling center per county, or worse, one for the entire state.

Fortunately, many businesses are stepping up to the plate to help citizens recycle these hazardous neurotoxin anti-Third World CFL's. Well, for at least 8 hours they did.

Yep. That was back in 2007.

Home Depot has stated that you can recycle by handing over one of these human-killers to one of its associates. Shows how much they care for their workers. Good thing they are illegal workers.

Here is something to think about: If Home Depot and Walmart alone sold nearly 300 million CFL's in 2007 (75 plus 193), that would mean nearly 1.5 tons of mercury were placed in America's homes that year. This does not count Europe and other "enlightened" countries.

And that's 1.5 tons each year. Every year! More and more mercury entering our homes and our environment.

Government. There to protect you.

(Thanks to M4GW)


[Update] It would seem that GE is working on new incandescent bulbs that will be just as efficient as CFL's.

Without the mercury.

We'll see if Congress reverses course and bans CFL's and their mercury and in turn mandate the use of GE's new incandescent bulbs.
 
Snap.com Popups

If they're driving you crazy, please click here to disable them on this website.




Trackbacks

No Trackbacks

Comments [RSS]
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)

Here is what a handful of random people think about this article. But first, the fine print:
The opinions expressed here, even where approved for display, do not necessarily reflect the opinions of this website, the management, or any other entity or organization, with the exception of the Vast Zionist Conspiracy. Those opinions we represent in style, yo. Please keep the language in these comments clean, as this is intended to be a family-friendly, work-friendly website. Comments not compliant with this policy will be edited for content where necessary. Abusive or otherwise illegal comments will be reported to the proper authorities, up to and including the aforementioned Vast Zionist Conspiracy. The Management cannot and will not be held responsible for commenters making a spectacle of themselves, even if The Management are the said commenters in question. In other words, don't take yourself so seriously, folks. We're all here to discuss the news, and more importantly, to have fun. Now go get yourself into some OCD treatment program—you obviously need it if you actually read all of this mess.

RecycleBill on 2009-09-20 21:16 #1
*I find it interesting that the government would push these products at the same time it is pushing the auto industry to eliminate mercury switches. Clearly, one hand of the EPA doesn't know what the other hand is doing.
Reply  
Jonathan on 2009-09-21 11:08 #2
*I remember playing with mercury in my hands in middle school. Some kids had broken into a defunct thermostat and we were all having a blast with it.

Nobody was stupid enough to drink it... but none of us died from playing with it either.

I would like to see the CFL mandate as leverage to reduce how seriously the law treats mercury. I would hate for salmon to be taken off the menu in coming years.
Reply  
captainfish on 2009-09-21 14:24 #3
*Jonathan, I am not sure I understand your point.

You want to see an increase in the CFL mandate? Yes, that would relax the influx of mercury in to your household. But, I doubt that would be a healthy thing.

The mercury you played with is different than the mercury that is in these bulbs. The CFL mercury is easily vaporized and inhaled. I think it may even be in a dust form.

The liquid mercury can't be easily absorbed through the skin, especially the palms.

But, I can nearly guarantee you that increasing CFL usage will increase the level of mercury in our land and water supplies. That WILL get in to our salmon and bird populations.

People thought the DDT caused problems with wildlife? Wait till mercury gets its foothold. And that does not just go away.
Reply  
Jonathan on 2009-09-21 15:11 #4
*I suppose my point is based on an anti-alarmist (and anti-environmentalist) perspective.

Your point about tons of mercury being dug out of the ground and put into our environment doesn't really phase me. If every single one of those bulbs fell out of a light fixture and shattered, then maybe. But if not, if people just illegally throw them in their trash, they are many layers that the mercury would have to work its way through, even before it gets compressed into a trash cube and set at the bottom of a landfill, which are usually far, far away from water supplies because of laws to prevent other contaminants from seeping through the ground.

As for the CFL mandate itself, I hate it. Same with "green car" initiatives. Both (as you say) do but more potent toxins into the air than they would without government involvement, and I do find it as ironic as you do. But I think saying that CFLs are going to kill us all is going a little overboard to make that point.

The factory workers are a different (and horrific) story. China isn't exactly known for their worker safety initiatives... and the article doesn't mention how much mercury they were exposed to, so it's hard to take it into context.

I guess, finally, if not for the mandate, CFLs would likely be banned by now. I don't want to see them banned, because I really like what they do for my electricity bill.
Reply  
captainfish on 2009-09-21 16:01 #5
*Ok. I gotcha. Well sure, I am taking the more dramatic approach. But, doesn't the left? Wasn't that the take over DDT? Isn't that the take of the global warming?

If it works for them, then it should work for me, right?

Haven't we heard about the plastics and diapers filling and destroying our landfills? Leaching toxins in to our water supplies?

And, not all landfills are lined. Not everyone uses landfills. Besides, the danger from CFL's mercury is not just from once they enter a landfill.

Note from my article that the primary danger from these CFL's is in the home. Break a bulb and you have a toxic spill and are told to evacuate the area. The mercury aerosolizes. If people throw away their fluorescent bulbs, they often break right then.

Corporations have a process of switching out their fluorescent bulbs. Most individuals will just chunk them in to their trash. That trash gets squished in trash trucks.

I know I am being a bit of an alarmist, but I can just see the future. After years of mandates and forced mercury usage, the enlightened Congress will find out that mercury is killing us. They will then turn around and mandate that CFL's be banned. They will then mandate a single gov't produced anti-mercury global-cooling bulb.

And, you and I are in perfect agreement on the whole issue of mandating something. Destroys the whole purpose of freedom of choice.

I agree that there is also no context on the Chinese worker's poisoning, but I don't see them working with CFL's much longer than 5 years. Besides, mercury is one of the most toxic heavy metals out there. Doesn't take much exposure to the right form of mercury.

Just take a look at the shots with mercury.
Reply  
Matt on 2010-04-16 20:04 #6
*Anyone care to guess what the number one single source of mercury polution in the U.S. is? That's right boys and girls - It's coal-burning power plants! A full 40% of domestic atmospheric mercury emissions in 1999 came from power plants, to the tune of 48 tons. The author states that the 9,000,000 bulbs sold in California last year means that 100 pounds of mercury was "removed from the ground and placed into the environment ready to do untold toxic damage". Not quite accurate. That figure is based on the old standard of 5mg of mercury per bulb. Today's bulbs average about 3mg or less. Why? Mercury is expensive and manufacturers have figured out how to use less in order to increase profits. In addition, as the bulb is used, most of the mercury becomes bound to the inside of the lightbulb. The EPA estimates that if a used CFL is broken, about 0.7 milligrams of mercury is released to the atmosphere. Also keep in mind that the mercury in that bulb can only do "untold damage" if it is not disposed of properly. Now consider if those 9 million bulbs had not been sold and 60 watt incandescent bulbs had been installed instead. I won't bore you with all the math, (the figures are out there if you care to look them up) but in a nutshell, that 60 watt bulb would require almost 500 pounds of coal to power it over an 8000 hour period, which is a little below the estimated 10,000 hour lifespan of a CFL. Burning that amount of coal would result in, on average, 5.8 milligrams of mercury being released. Quick math tells me that this would mean that those 9 million bulbs would cause 114 pounds of mercury to be dug up from the ground and then released into the environment where it would undoubtedly do harm. Even assuming every last CFL that was sold was broken and a full 5mg of mercury was released from each, had the CFL's not been available an additional 14 pounds of mercury would have entered the atmopshere. And consider this - If a CFL is improperly disposed of, where does the mercury end up? In a landfill. Mosty likely a regulated, monitored, sealed landfill. Where does the mercury from a coal-burning power plant end up? Wherever the wind blows it.

So with that in mind, my question is this - Would you rather know that the snake is in your house, but safely contained, or would you rather have the snake lurking outside your home without you even being aware of it?
Reply  

Add Comment

HTML-Tags will be converted to Entities.
Gravatar/MyBlogLog/Favatar/Pavatar/Pavatar author images supported.
Enclosing asterisks marks text as bold (*word*), underscore are made via _word_.
Standard emoticons like :-) and ;-) are converted to images.
BBCode format allowed
E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for E-Mail notifications

To prevent automated Bots from commentspamming, please enter the string you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.
CAPTCHA