The Ghost of Snapped Shot

Or, welcome to my low-maintenance heck.

<<
 a
 >
>>
Something Odd

Does this look genuine to you?
... this way comes. Without any prior warning from the photo wires, we're treated to a series of photographs of a funeral procession for a ten-year-old girl, reported to have been killed by a rubber bullet fired by IDF soldiers. But, as with many reports originating from the region, the lines are somewhat unclear. For instance, the first story I see about it is from yesterday, even though the event was reported by the photo wires to have happened on Tuesday. To make matters worse, there are only a handful of stories about it, at the time of this writing, it being worth only 8 stories. (And yes, I tried alternate searches as well.)

What really stinks to high heaven about this story, though, is a fact that none of these reports conveys: Much like their anti-war counterparts here in the United States, not a single one of these anti-"Apartheid" wall protests happens without being covered by any number of photographers. So why is it that after a girl is injured at such a protest, is there not a single photograph of her on the wires from the protest itself? Surely, the photographers would've noticed such a young girl being treated brutally, and would have proceeded to take hundreds of sympathetic pictures!

I mean, it's possible to explain it away by suggesting that the IDF confiscated film from every photographer on-site, but based on the photographic coverage we've seen from that area over the past 6 years, do you really think that's what's going on? Perhaps it was the Palestinians who confiscated the film, but really -- wouldn't that have merited at least a story about the event?

Finally, check out the professionally-printed "funeral" photograph on the gravesite. One doesn't usually find such detail, mere days after a little girl's life is abruptly ended--that is, unless one is intent on trying to score a very cynical political point.

There's definitely something very wrong with this story. I'll be keeping an eye on things to see what kind of reaction it gets in the international press. Keep reading below the fold for the handful of photos on the wire about this so far.

Update: The story is gaining traction, being featured on the front page of the "moderate" English-language Palestine Times.

Not to be too conspiratorial, but do y'all think there's any chance that the Palestinian government (or rather, a group of Palestinians, be it Fatah or Hamas) did this? It seems to be an awfully efficient way to try and re-direct some of the current fratricidal violence in the region back to the "evil Zionists," doesn't it?

Update: The more I see the "posterized" memorial photograph of this girl, the more convinced I am that this is heartless propaganda. The IDF has opened an investigation into her death, so we'll just have to wait and see what the truth is. I'm still scanning the wires, though, so we'll see if there are any pictures of the actual protest.

CAMERA reports some details on this case, including the blockbuster, "Police sources said on Sunday that autopsy findings indicated Aramin could have been killed by concussion from a shock grenade or by a thrown rock. However, they said, the findings were inconsistent with her having been killed by a rubber bullet: No bullet wounds were found on her body, and the skull injury that caused her death was a large one, whereas rubber bullets, even if they do not penetrate, usually make small wounds."

With that, I think I finally have enough of a story to cross-post this over at NewsBusters. Fair NB readers, I hope that you will not be disappointed by my work so far! f 10-year-old Palestinian girl Abir Aramin hold posters during a memorial for her at their school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Sunday, Jan. 21, 2007. Abir was killed Tuesday in a clash between stone throwers and Israeli border police during a demonstration against Israel's separation barrier in Anata. Israeli police spokesman Moshe Fintzy said an internal investigation into Abir's death had been opened. (AP Photo/Muhammed Muheisen)


A Palestinian classmates of 10-year-old Palestinian girl Abir Aramin holds a poster of her portrait during a memorial for her at their school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Sunday, Jan. 21, 2007. Abir was killed Tuesday in a clash between stone throwers and Israeli border police during a demonstration against Israel's separation barrier in Anata. Israeli police spokesman Moshe Fintzy said an internal investigation into Abir's death had been opened. (AP Photo/Muhammed Muheisen)


Palestinian classmates of 10-year-old Palestinian girl Abir Aramin hold posters of her portrait during a memorial for her at their school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Sunday, Jan. 21, 2007. Abir was killed Tuesday in a clash between stone throwers and Israeli border police during a demonstration against Israel's separation barrier in Anata. Israeli police spokesman Moshe Fintzy said an internal investigation into Abir's death had been opened. (AP Photo/Muhammed Muheisen)


Palestinian classmates and friends of 10-year-old Palestinian girl Abir Aramin hold posters of her portrait during a memorial for her at their school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Sunday, Jan. 21, 2007. Abir was killed Tuesday in a clash between stone throwers and Israeli border police during a demonstration against Israel's separation barrier in Anata. Israeli police spokesman Moshe Fintzy said an internal investigation into Abir's death had been opened. (AP Photo/Muhammed Muheisen)


Palestinian classmates of 10-year-old Palestinian girl Abir Aramin hold posters with of portrait during a memorial for her at their school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Sunday, Jan. 21, 2007. Abir was killed Tuesday in a clash between stone throwers and Israeli border police during a demonstration against Israel's separation barrier in Anata. Israeli police spokesman Moshe Fintzy said an internal investigation into Abir's death had been opened. (AP Photo/Muhammed Muheisen)


Palestinian girls hold banners depicting ten-year-old girl Abeer Aramin during a commemoration ceremony at her school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Ramallah, January 21, 2007. Abeer was critically wounded during a protest against the controversial Israeli barrier in Anata and later died in hospital, Palestinian witnesses said. REUTERS/Ammar Awad (WEST BANK)


A Palestinian girl holds a banner depicting ten-year-old girl Abeer Aramin during a commemoration ceremony at her school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Ramallah, January 21, 2007. Abeer was critically wounded during a protest against the controversial Israeli barrier in Anata and later died in hospital, Palestinian witnesses said. REUTERS/Ammar Awad (WEST BANK)


Palestinian students hold Palestinian flags and banners depicting ten-year-old girl Abeer Aramin during a commemoration ceremony at her school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Ramallah, January 21, 2007. Abeer was critically wounded during a protest against the controversial Israeli barrier in Anata and later died in hospital, Palestinian witnesses said. REUTERS/Loay Abu Haykel (WEST BANK)


Palestinian students hold Palestinian flags and banners depicting ten-year-old girl Abeer Aramin during a commemoration ceremony at her school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Ramallah, January 21, 2007. Abeer was critically wounded during a protest against the controversial Israeli barrier in Anata and later died in hospital, Palestinian witnesses said. REUTERS/Loay Abu Haykel (WEST BANK)


Palestinian girls hold banners depicting ten-year-old girl Abeer Aramin during a commemoration ceremony at her school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Ramallah, January 21, 2007. Abeer was critically wounded during a protest against the controversial Israeli barrier in Anata and later died in hospital, Palestinian witnesses said. REUTERS/Ammar Awad (WEST BANK)


A Palestinian girl holds a banner depicting ten-year-old girl Abeer Aramin during a commemoration ceremony at her school in the West Bank village of Anata, near Ramallah, January 21, 2007. Abeer was critically wounded during a protest against the controversial Israeli barrier in Anata and later died in hospital, Palestinian witnesses said. REUTERS/Ammar Awad (WEST BANK)


Palestinian mourners read the obituary of ten-year-old Abir Aramin as father Bassam, top second from right, in a local newspaper at her wake in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Saturday, Jan. 20, 2007. Hope is getting Aramin through the worst days of his life. The Palestinian peace activist is mourning his 10-year-old daughter, killed in a clash with Israeli border police this week, but is drawing strength from the embrace of his Israeli friends. Aramin, an ex-Fatah gunman, has been touring Israeli high schools with former Israeli soldiers to preach co-existence, and says his daughter's death has only strengthened his belief that the conflict between the two peoples cannot be solved by force. (AP Photo/Kevin Frayer)


Palestinian Ahmed Aramin listens as his mother Salwa, center, and a relative read prayers from the Quran, Islam's holy book, as they sit in his ten year old sister Abir's bedroom at the family's home in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Saturday, Jan. 20, 2007. Hope is getting Abir's father Bassam Aramin through the worst days of his life. The Palestinian peace activist is mourning his 10-year-old daughter, killed in a clash with Israeli border police this week, but is drawing strength from the embrace of his Israeli friends. Aramin, an ex-Fatah gunman, has been touring Israeli high schools with former Israeli soldiers to preach co-existence, and says his daughter's death has only strengthened his belief that the conflict between the two peoples cannot be solved by force.(AP Photo/Kevin Frayer)


Palestinian Bassam Aramin is seen at the wake for his ten-year-old daughter Abir Aramin in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Saturday, Jan. 20, 2007. Hope is getting Aramin through the worst days of his life. The Palestinian peace activist is mourning his 10-year-old daughter, killed in a clash with Israeli border police this week, but is drawing strength from the embrace of his Israeli friends. Aramin, an ex-Fatah gunman, has been touring Israeli high schools with former Israeli soldiers to preach co-existence, and says his daughter's death has only strengthened his belief that the conflict between the two peoples cannot be solved by force. (AP Photo/Kevin Frayer)


Palestinian Bassam Aramin, left, is greeted by mourners at the wake for his ten-year-old daughter Abir Aramin in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Saturday, Jan. 20, 2007. Hope is getting Aramin through the worst days of his life. The Palestinian peace activist is mourning his 10-year-old daughter, killed in a clash with Israeli border police this week, but is drawing strength from the embrace of his Israeli friends. Aramin, an ex-Fatah gunman, has been touring Israeli high schools with former Israeli soldiers to preach co-existence, and says his daughter's death has only strengthened his belief that the conflict between the two peoples cannot be solved by force. (AP Photo/Kevin Frayer)


Palestinian Ahmed Aramin listens as his mother and a relative read prayers from the Quran, Islam's holy book, as they sit in the bedroom of his ten-year-old sister Abir at the family home in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Saturday, Jan. 20, 2007. Hope is getting Abir's father Bassam Aramin through the worst days of his life. The Palestinian peace activist is mourning his 10-year-old daughter, killed in a clash with Israeli border police this week, but is drawing strength from the embrace of his Israeli friends. Aramin, an ex-Fatah gunman, has been touring Israeli high schools with former Israeli soldiers to preach co-existence, and says his daughter's death has only strengthened his belief that the conflict between the two peoples cannot be solved by force. (AP Photo/Kevin Frayer)


Palestinian Bassam Aramin sits in the bedroom of his ten-year-old daughter Abir Aramin at the family home in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Saturday, Jan. 20, 2007. Hope is getting Aramin through the worst days of his life. The Palestinian peace activist is mourning his 10-year-old daughter, killed in a clash with Israeli border police this week, but is drawing strength from the embrace of his Israeli friends. Aramin, an ex-Fatah gunman, has been touring Israeli high schools with former Israeli soldiers to preach co-existence, and says his daughter's death has only strengthened his belief that the conflict between the two peoples cannot be solved by force.(AP Photo/Kevin Frayer)


A Palestinian relative holds family pictures as Salwa Aramin, the mother of ten year old Abir Aramin, reads prayers from the Quran, Islam's holy book, as they sit in her daughter's bedroom at the family home in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Saturday, Jan. 20, 2007. Hope is getting Abir's father Bassam Aramin through the worst days of his life. The Palestinian peace activist is mourning his 10-year-old daughter, killed in a clash with Israeli border police this week, but is drawing strength from the embrace of his Israeli friends. Aramin, an ex-Fatah gunman, has been touring Israeli high schools with former Israeli soldiers to preach co-existence, and says his daughter's death has only strengthened his belief that the conflict between the two peoples cannot be solved by force. (AP Photo/Kevin Frayer)


A memorial poster showing ten year old Palestinian Abir Aramin is seen on the door of the family home as relatives gather in the West Bank village of Anata, near Jerusalem, Saturday, Jan. 20, 2007. Hope is getting Abir's father Bassam Aramin through the worst days of his life. The Palestinian peace activist is mourning his 10-year-old daughter, killed in a clash with Israeli border police this week, but is drawing strength from the embrace of his Israeli friends. Aramin, an ex-Fatah gunman, has been touring Israeli high schools with former Israeli soldiers to preach co-existence, and says his daughter's death has only strengthened his belief that the conflict between the two peoples cannot be solved by force. (AP Photo/Kevin Frayer)



------>

 Tags: ammar awad kevin frayer muhammed muheisen AP REUTERS #Intifada


Comments:

#1 captainfish 21-Jan-2007
Guess they don't need International Aid money since they can afford the nice clothes they are wearing and the fancy posters. Those things are not cheap, especially when done on a rush job.

From the look of the photos, it looks like they took a circuitous route to get to the cemetary. I don't know, I still like the way we Americans conduct our funeral services..... reserved and retrospective. And some even talk of love, peace and forgiveness. Guess that would be too much to ask for over there.
#2 ric ottaiano 22-Jan-2007
sometimes all i have energy to say is that the ghoulishness of these people makes me ill...
#3 calista 31-Aug-2007
thats a silly statement. actually this entire site is silly. so much energy for what? to try to prove this girl was not killed? she is being propagandized? why is that? because people should know what the isarelis are doing? you are all a bunch of hypocrites.
#4 ruth james 29-Jan-2008
you complete and utter morons. I was in anata at the time of this event. its not fake. it wasn't a demo - she was walking ot school, hence no photographers.
she died. she was shot. by IDF. thats what happened.
There are different spellings of her name oh you clever clever people because she is arabic - do you read arabic? if so prehaps you could give the direct translation of abeer/abir/abear?
Powered by Snarf ยท Contact Us